The Ghost and Mrs. Muir: Film Review
1947 Haunting Romance Featuring Rex Harrison and Gene Tierney
Oct 27, 2008
The year is 1900. Mrs. Lucy Muir is determined upon renting Gull Cottage--overlooking an expanse of England's coastline. Mr. Coombe (Robert Coote) of the local rental agency insists (without clarification) that this cottage is not suitable for her. Contrary to his opinions, Mrs. Muir demands to visit the cottage.
After entering the front door and listening to a brief introduction about the home from Mr. Coombe, Mrs. Muir opens a side door to a dark living room. She is greeted by a large, foreboding picture of the late seaman, and original owner of Gull Cottage, Captain Daniel Gregg (Rex Harrison).
After a brief tour of the downstairs, Mr. Coombe allows Mrs. Muir to visit the upstairs. Here, in Captain Gregg's observatory, the haunting, romance and fun begins.
General Mood of the Film
This is not a color film. Black, white and shades of muted grays enhance the sense of foreboding. Though a plus regarding mood, the black and white filming deters from the splendid panoramic views of the coastline.
Characterizations
Rex Harrison portrays a short-tempered, borderline potty-mouthed (for that time period), son-of-the-sea, ghostly, sea captain. He loathes visitors and takes fiendish delight scaring them off. His rationalization? He has plans for his house--slight problem, his plans were cut short by his untimely death.
Harrison gives the spectre of Captain Gregg depth and warmth. Despite the Captain's brusque demeanor, therein resides a tender heart. Harrison's performance is witty and full of charm.
Gene Tierney as Mrs. Muir, gives a suitable performance--somewhat lackluster, however. It is difficult to believe Mrs. Muir has a strong internal muscle when she is portrayed as weak, frail--iin need of protection and rest. Maureen O'Hara's fire would've been more appropriate/believable for this role.
Supporting cast does well. Robert Coote is convincing as the reluctant rental agent. George Sanders (Miles Fairley), plays Mrs. Muir's charming, scheming, rival love interest--convincingly. Edna Best (Ms. Martha Huggins), the maid, is believable and helps to center the film. She delivers the down-to-earth reality perspective. Her role could have been written more extensively.
Mrs. Muir's stifling in-laws (played by Isobel Elsom and Victoria Horne) have short parts. They are briefly, yet, happily tormented by the Captain.
There are a couple of short scenes featuring Natalie Wood as Mrs. Muir's little girl, Anna Muir. The musical score highlights and enhances the characterizations and overall tone of the film as well.
Additional Film Information
- Director: Joseph L. Mankiewicz;
- Producer: Fred Kohlmar;
- Writer: Philip Dunne (screenplay);
- Novel: Written by R.A. Dick;
- Musical Score: Bernard Herrmmann (Academy Nomination 1947);
- Cinematography: Charles Lang; and,
- A Twentieth Century Fox presentation
Though this film does not have a rating, because of the haunting nature, it may not be suitable for very young or young children. It is available on DVD and video. However, despite some inconsistencies within the film, for older viewers, this classic is definitely a plus for celebrating Halloween.
Featurettes
For anyone who loves the older movie classics, the previews include:
- All About Eve;
- The Day the Earth Stood Still;
- How Green was My Valley; and
- An Affair to Remember
There is also a short documentary detailing the highlights of Rex Harrison's personal life and theater/movie career. This is well done and informative including reflections from Mr. Harrison's biographer, comments from his sons and Charlton Heston who starred opposite Harrison in the Agony and the Ecstasy (Michelangelo's assignment to paint the Sistine Chapel).
More Information
 |
